Tuesday, July 05, 2022

Treaty - can you trust even a Westerner to keep his written word ?


While I love our tradition of law,  I would never trust a lawyer or the law without its principle .
And who says a mere title gives you licence to do what you like ?. Real estate is  make believe territory,  whatever your land ambitions and race . 


 

Of all the people I think we should NOT trust its  those with  the narrowminded idea who insist on property rights because the  Western liberal tradition does not worship the power that property / territory gives people but is  ONLY EVER  meant to be USED  TO HONOR the responsibility  it gives people to share the benefits of it . The aboriginal fisherwoman in the picture knew and honored this  

Without the latter,  our faith says take away both if the latter is ignored . 
Any treaty that doesn't bring the above consensus won't be worth the paper its printed on . 

Before Australians will agree to a treaty they need to share something deeper than the law of property rights  themselves . The territorial imperative is natural and a useful diver but IT IS not binding in on- ground terms for humans ( territorial responsibility is a burden too )
.
Think inspirationally . We can, should and have learned to share the territory. That's the sort of sharing we can and should celebrate . Diversity of tasks not diversity of rights .Unity of property rights as we all own it all - called a commonwealth.
If you want more than you have. ask God for it -- not me !

The division of labor that industrialization has brought us all,  is a basically a good thing.
  Harking back to the past is only helpful if we take what is good and necessary from it , And there is good there - no doubt about it , The quickfixers  and blame in colonialization (Half full = training in new ways ) must be resisted because change can have its half full side .  
East ,West and Aboriginal are sources of good things to bring forward 
Lets bring us all forward and not fall for the wasted old and childish nonsense of us all having our own little empires. Competition alone achieves nothing .
Vaclav Smil's   book on "How the world really works"  sets out a  framework that works and can be used to guide us through many of the remaining threats . Building on foundations is what adults do not idealistically falling for every new progress idea sold in the media.

Dynasties are dumb and done for
. Note how adults who have never grown up still believe in them 

There is no going back to subsistence . We have to build family beyond the dependency of space control .
The great challenge for the future then is how to fish carefully with bigger boats and still adopt the ownership and stewardship traditions of the past.   
The wonderful story of the aboriginal fisherwoman of Benelong.


2 comments:

Little John said...


Let's all agree that white or black this idea that we can give anyone a right to an income through land is wrong and quite perverse.
Wars never finish until we give this madness up and live in the freedom of forgiveness ,sharing and new starts -- and yet we have left and right going to hell just to get more property for one . Property is a trap because it guarantees no genuine income and prosperity
When anyone from any culture uses the worst aspect of capitalism to justify their desire for more property and income I say --- evil. Go find another island to live on. This is NOT how the first peoples wanted it or how anyone now wants it.

Little John said...

All about "THE VOICE " at the moment . Feb 2023
What if this is just largely a cry for help?.
Now if it was, most of us can all understand that. Life is difficult .
Are our Native australinns making that cry or the dogooders who can't even spend a few hours in the Alice making all the noise .
Some of those people just need to shut up !

What good then will giving such people more opportunities to be heard? They are so loud on the ABC we just switch them off!
Most importantly, what good like people who yell in anger do to
....give them the last word .

Clearly, if the last line above is true we should vote no and listen more carefully round the table . Things are on edge but anger will only push us all off the edge .